Yahoo 知識+ 將於 2021 年 5 月 4 日 (美國東岸時間) 停止服務,而 Yahoo 知識+ 網站現已轉為僅限瀏覽模式。其他 Yahoo 資產或服務,或你的 Yahoo 帳戶將不會有任何變更。你可以在此服務中心網頁進一步了解 Yahoo 知識+ 停止服務的事宜,以及了解如何下載你的資料。

? 發問於 社會及文化宗教及靈性 · 3 年前

因果論是宿命論,還是神論是宿命論?

佛講因果,通於「三世」,即過去、現在與未來世。

佛的因果論可以說是宿命論,也可以說不是宿命論

說佛的因果論是宿命論,是因為「現在世」所發生的一切事(果報)決定於過去世所造作的某些事(業因)。天生命好(果報),如聰明、五官美好,是過去多造善業(善業因)。天生命不好(果報),如醜陋、四肢不全,是過去世多做惡業(惡業因)。天生如是,不能改變。

說佛的因果論不是宿命論,是因為「現在世」將會發生的事(果報)與「現在世」所造作的某些事(業因)有關。「現在世」廣積善因,則「現在世」或「未來世」,當機緣成熟之時,好的果報便會出現。

說信神是宿命論,是因為信神者認為神是萬物創造者,是萬物的主宰者,即是說,人由出生至死後都是由神安排。人是罪人,故人活在災劫苦難,要神審判(舊約)或耶穌的救贖(新約)才可以免罪(得救),才可以升天(天堂)。

6 個解答

評分
  • 匿名
    2 年前

    Gov't is killing you with high frequency electricity.Theotokos Virgin Mary gave prayers to "Schema-nun Antonia" on how to save aborted babies from hell. If you pray these prayers diligently, aborted babies are released from hell. On each painted nail there are 40 demons. Smoking is censer to the devil.Using foul language calls upon Pagan deities (aka demons); Holy Spirit departs on 7 meters. People who use drugs see demons who cleverly disguise themselves as ghosts and aliens.America will be last country to switch to Euro (antichrist's world currency). Contraceptives = abortion;using contraceptives for 1 year = 5 aborted kids.Miscarriages happen because of high heels; cesarean because of tight pants (second generation cesarean will be infertile).Unbaptized aborted/miscarried/unborn babies burn in hell for until Final Judgement; if pregnant, keep the kid and deliver at home because kids are chipped using IVs and vaccines in hospitals. Dentists and doctors chip patients secretly. Ultrasound leads to mark of the beast; don't do ultrasound, please. Abortion leads to breast cancer; a demon is released from hell for each aborted kid. Dogs can become possessed; don't keep dogs inside your home [Pelageya of Ryazan]. Walmart has technology to administer mark of the beast to those who have cat bacteria in their stomachs; stay away from cats [Afanasiy Sidyachiy]. Next false flag is the Statue of Liberty. Above earth there is ice (hemisphere); when rockets go up they bring ice down from upper sky to lower sky; ice stuck in lower sky will fall on us during Apocalypse. Earth is flat; earth stands on 3 pillars (the Most Holy Trinity); pillars stand on water at zero Kelvin; underneath this ice there is a bubble; and then the abyss. Zodiac is planetary prison of demons; don't believe in horoscopes or you'll exhibit the traits of the trapped demons. Most thoughts and dreams are from demons; demons never do good. Sleep fully clothed; pray the Jesus prayer. Pray to your guardian angel to have normal sleep. Vyacheslav Krasheninnikov was the last prophet before Apostle John (who wrote the Book of Revelation), Enoch, Elijah, resurrected Seraphim of Sarov, and resurrected Sergius of Radonezh will preach against the antichrist. Humans were created about 7525 years ago. Birds participate in time creation. It's a sin to kill birds. Dinosaurs live under our level; they will get out through sinkholes and lakes; to kill them, go for their nerves. Save the birds; but kill the dinosaurs. First dinosaur will come out of Volga River in Russia. Scientists don't see dinosaurs under our level because of radiation. Sinkholes happen because people dig for resources underground and because earth is heating up. Demons grow human skin (from a sample taken during abduction) and put it on so as to look like us. Demons will invite people to be healed inside their UFOs; those who go will be like zombies after. Gov't provides demons with diamonds and allows demons to abduct people. If you're being abducted, slowly pray the Jesus prayer. Don't panic. Demons use diamonds and souls to power their UFO craft. The bigger the diamond, the more it lasts. Demons have 4 UFO bases: 1)moon 2)inside fake mountain Kailash in Tibet 3)in lake Baikal in Russia 4)in Atlantis which is underneath the Mariana Trench in Pacific Ocean. There are no aliens. Nobody lives on other planets. Airplanes that go down are hit by demons because they need the airspace to fight Jesus. Antichrist is pale with red eyes. He's possessed by Satan since he's 12 years old [Lavrentiy Chernigovskiy]. He flies super fast; deceived people will say: "Christ is here; Christ is there" when he's flying from one city to the next very fast. He wears gloves to hide long nails. He's surrounded by demons who appear as angels of light. Antichrist will trick people that he can do mountain moving and resurrection using holograms/hypnosis; fire from the sky is real because of pollution gases in the atmosphere. Antichrist will have food only for 6 months; then he will feed his 666ed people flour from mashed up turtles (Tavrion Batozskiy), but this won't be enough because 666ed people are 10 times as angry and 7 times as hungry as normal people even though 666ed people became shorter (3-4 feet tall = 80 - 120 cm) because nanochips do function of organs (organs diminish) [Nilus Myrrhgusher]. If you have a lot of nanochips in your forearm, then you will not be able to make proper Orthodox sign of the cross (last mercy for you will be to cut your forearm off). Nanochips are sprayed by the gov't using chemtrails; they're also in gov't food and medicine; so, eat food from your own garden. In case garden is destroyed by ice from the sky, have chickens for eggs and goats for milk (Paisios). Lipstick contains cells of aborted fetuses, dog fat, and placenta; human flesh is in McDonalds, Pepsi, toothpaste, antiaging, anticancer, vaccines, perfume, etc.; that's why you should not be using anything that modern society has to offer. You're better off hiding within a 10-12 people group in order to escape Apocalypse. During Apocalypse, Chrtistians will eat dirt from under pussywillowtree as it's filled with tears of Theotokos Virgin Mary; this water will flee if a 666ed person tries to get it. Barcode is Druid black magic curse; QRcode is Mayan curse; when food is scanned, it becomes dead because laser is a substance from demons. Don't go into a UFO to be healed by demons. Green 666 is given by isotope rays on wrist or forehead when people stretch hands to receive small plastic grey card with no name on it (World Passport). It doesn't just have to be during this procedure (could be anything you sign up for or anywhere where there is a secret scanner); biometrics (fingerprints, eyes scan) or getting picture for passport are very dangerous because they could mark you secretly. Gabriel Urgebadze said that they do it on index finger when they scan your finger. Basically, try to avoid new documents at all cost. Police will microchip and isotope ray people on highways. Chipped people will be influenced by computers to take grey plastic card; but when they do, green mark by isotope rays is given on forehead/wrist. Food stores will isotope ray people too. Antichrist will also release prisoners to mark people. Reject 666 at all cost because it leads to permanent hell. If you're about to be marked, pray the Jesus prayer. Hide with Orthodox Christians to escape 666; leave all electronics behind so that antichrist's minions can't track you; burn documents because they're from Satan. The Most Holy Trinity gives you a name during baptism; devil gives an antiname during antibaptism (ex. Social Security Number). People who die with these Satanic documents go to concentration camp in hell to await Final Judgement; once the BEAST Computer is burned down, souls will be released for Final Judgement. That's why you should give back documents of your deceased relatives back to the gov't so that the gov't cancels these digital antichristian names given during antibaptism by the beast system; or just burn these documents because gov't could get upset and could send demons to mark you because of this outright act of defiance. Prophecy from half a millenium ago describes Final Judgement like this: Jesus was very upset with people who had little boards (plastic cards) in their hands because they wanted discount from the antichrist. Give to charity in the name of Archangel Michael; he rescues people from temporary hell twice a year [at midnight between September 18 and September 19 and similarly on November 20-21; pray at these times on your knees remembering the deceased by names (adding "and relatives by flesh up to Adam") so that they are rescued if they're in hell] (or brings them up a level, that is, to a level with less punishment; eventually, people are freed). Feed the pigeons; when pigeons bow down, people are saved from temporary hell. It's a big sin to remember the dead with wreaths (because demons put these wreaths on their necks if they're in hell with their hands tied up behind their back while hanging by their hands), meat, alcohol, sweets, and worldly music. Demons print icons of saints in newspapers so that you throw these newspapers in the trash blaspheming these saints. Crosses on soles of shoes and back of pants are blasphemy. Demons make carpets with crosses and put them on sidewalks so that people walk on crosses. Playing cards mock how Jesus suffered on the cross: clubs (cross on which Jesus was crucified), diamonds (four nails Jesus was crucified with), hearts (sponge with vinegar that Jesus was given to drink),spades (spear with which Jesus was pierced).Cremation is devil worship; only blasphemers such as Lenin should be burned; if Lenin is buried, earth will be polluted, and China will attack Russia because of this.After China attacks Russia, Ruski Orthodox Tsar (shown by resurrected Seraphim of Sarov) will come to power in Russia;this Tsar will slay traitors inside church and gov't; as a result, Russia will be the only country not under the antichrist.Ecumenism = 263 heresies;each heresy leads to hell. In 2006 in Moscow (that's why Moscow will sink),representatives from most religions signed a document where it says that all religions worship the same Supreme Being [aka the devil]. Priests who participate in ecumenism will have Pagans walking on their heads in hell. Arkhimandrite Antonin Kapustin left a prophecy that John the Baptist's living space will become a church and it will be blessed by forerunner of antichrist; Patriarch Kirill of Russia blessed this church.When priests pray for current gov't (instead of praying for future Tsar),Jesus gets up from His throne and turns His back to them. Forgive me.

    資料來源: Women wear headscarves tied at the front to prevent headaches from sky pushing down and to prevent throat cancer; forgive me. Edit: Megatsunami for New York will be 450 yards; then engulfed-in-lava Los Angeles will be flooded too; then asteroid destroys Gulf of Mexico; only Alaska, Eurasia, and Africa remain (obviously without coasts); forgive me. Edit: 1st big earthquake in Russia; 2nd bigger one in China; 3rd biggest will be in the USofA (Greek Orthodox monk Elidiy from Africa); forgive me.
  • 3 年前

    有宿命論。佛教所說的說宿知命通。地藏經裏說過。宿知命通意思是因為上世有修為,所以今世便很快知道自己在現世的使命。每事似有人指導路向,助你加快修成。我個人比較喜歡佛教的說法。

  • 善知識法喜

    關於因果

    佛陀見

    世界凡夫由於不瞭解此刻當下現前的意義

    因此 借以“大眾都能體會的因果”來說明

    基本是將因分成“緣,因”

    而果亦是因與緣

    於是

    大眾能理解“輪迴”的存在

    以及“遠離第一因”的追尋

    以是故

    以凡夫而言

    因果就變成 是宿命也是自命造作

    佛如此教導凡夫

    是為了使凡夫遠離

    神造與神授等等的觀念

    而對於尋求真實智慧者而言

    因緣與果

    都只是組合過程的智慧

    以上

  • ?
    Lv 6
    3 年前

    佛教說的是「因緣法則」,「因果關係」

    世間所有的事都跟因緣離不開干係,所以說十二因緣法

    那麼因果關係是指種了什麼因,便會有什麼果報

    但,這不叫宿命論

    舉個例子來說,某個人種了某種因,在某個時刻因與緣相遇

    會開車子撞到人,因與緣相遇而產生的果報

    結果,對方腿斷了、受傷了,這個因緣發生了,果報也產生了

    在一般人看來,真衰~~這是件壞事、壞因緣!!

    但實際上「鏡緣無好醜,自心起分別」,果報是必然的,只是看如何去處理圓融

    趕快救助傷患送醫、勤於慰問並體諒幫對方?

    趕快逃離現場,撇清責任,以避免財務賠償損失及刑責?

    不管如何的處理方式⋯⋯都會有不同的結果

    所以,因果,並不是宿命論

    它只是業報來了,您要如何去處理而己

    佛陀教導我們,處理事情遠離貪、瞋、痴

    圓融又清淨,那來什麼宿命論呢?

  • 匿名
    3 年前

    .

    宿命論 , 就是固定, 不可變論

    因果論 , 是自己可創造改變論

    你又說 :「現在世」廣積善因,則「現在世」或「未來世」,當機緣成熟之時,好的果報便會出現。

    那究竟是能變? 還是不能變 ? 矛盾的顛三倒四 , 不知說什麼 ?

    .

  • 匿名
    3 年前

    因果論就是自然定律,人類用數學來加以推演。真正懂得的人就知道,法爾如是,並非神論或宿命論。

還有問題嗎?立即提問即可得到解答。