Yahoo 知識+ 將於 2021 年 5 月 4 日 (美國東岸時間) 停止服務，而 Yahoo 知識+ 網站現已轉為僅限瀏覽模式。其他 Yahoo 資產或服務，或你的 Yahoo 帳戶將不會有任何變更。你可以在此服務中心網頁進一步了解 Yahoo 知識+ 停止服務的事宜，以及了解如何下載你的資料。
Previous question: Atheists, what was the origin of all matter of the universe?
Since you blocked me I can't answer, but the origin of matter is the result of energy particle collisions in the early universe. Not only is this known, but it can be demonstrated in any particle collider. Not a mystery in any way.
@Nigel: Yes particle collisions. Energy can exist in a particle form. For example, light is made up of particles called photons. Under the right conditions, high energy collisions can create matter. As I already said, we do this regularly in particle colliders.
@Yossarian: Neat book, but he's wrong. Quantum fluctuations require negative energy provided by gravitational fields. No universe = no spacetime or mass. No spacetime or mass = no gravity. No gravity = no quantum fluctuations. Sadly, the origin of the singularity and what caused it to expand are still a mystery.
@Someone who cares: Not entirely true. Although, as I mentioned above, quantum fluctuations are ruled out of being the origin of the singularity in the big bang, they can indeed create matter from nothing.
@NDMA: We do not yet know the origin of the singularity or what caused it to expand, but when it did, it produced MASSIVE energy. So much so that collisions at EXTREMELY high velocities was not only possible, but inevitable. By the way, your understanding of what happens in particle colliders is very off. ENERGY particles (not matter) collide and PRODUCE matter under the right conditions. You just need to read more on the subject. You understanding is a basic over-view, not a true understanding.
@NDMA: "Perhaps you should try reading past the cover" -- That's a wrong assertion too. My info above is why he's incorrect. The math of quantum fluctuations shows that there is a slight lean on the phenomenon towards the matter side over the anti matter side. Usually both particles annihilate each other, but the lean towards the matter side allows for some matter to come out intact.
9 個解答
- NDMALv 78 年前
Cool, so where did he not yet existing material world get a particle colllider to make the matter?
As a follow up - a particle collider guides particles at very high speed - near the speed of light, along a pathway using magnetism. The result is particles collide and are broken apart. You are arguing the collision does the exact opposite of what is observed.
EddieJ: Perhaps you should try reading past the cover - even the author admits he failed to make the case and that his scenario is impossible because if it were as he asserted there should be equal amounts of antimatter in the universe.
Math is nice but you seem to be avoiding one thing. We have actual experiments showing the conversion of energy into matter. In those experiments that conversion was the product of consciousness. The conscious attempt to measure the particle - therefore not just a blank consciousness but a willful consciousness. Your argument is based not on actual observations but math, theoretical physics. My position is based on observed results of experiments empirical science. Empirical science always trumps theoretical science because empirical science is based on actual evidence!
You certainly are free to disagree with any interpretation of the evidence, and I fully expect you will! But disagreeing with an interpretation of the evidence, is not a refutation of either the interpretation you disagree with, or the evidence itself.
I am aware of the mathematical bias you refer to, but the overwhelming evidence of negative and positive symmetry seen throughout natural systems in the universe makes that bias argument an argument based on the exception and for that exception to make a difference one must relay on miracles.
- 匿名8 年前
Oh relax. Its a troll. I got blocked after reply with only two words. Thats a record for me. Itll be hard to break but i damn well am gonna try!
- 匿名8 年前
Partlicle collisions?
- ?Lv 78 年前
Has "American for America" , "Top Contributor American for America" changed their name to A4A?
They have blocked many atheists.
It is not because the answers are insulting or impolite.
- 8 年前
Not an athiest, but the origin of all matter is from other matter, or energy. God created the earth from existing materials. Matter cannot be created or destroyed, only changed form or to/from energy. God himself has been around forever, so has the matter he is made of.
- Anne ArkeyLv 78 年前
That guy blocks everybody who admits they're an atheist. Then, he asks questions of atheists.
Anyway, his post got deleted.
- 匿名8 年前
I've said it before...I'll say it again, don't give that guy any attention.
