who would win a fight between all the captains from the Star Trek series? sort of celeb death-match style?

Kirk, hands down. No one else since has wanted to "get their hands dirty". Sure, they might throw a punch, but once you're down, they extend a hand to try to help you back up. Kirk wasn't afraid to finish off his enemy.

I would think Kirk would win but, I think Picard would have an advantage. The Enterprises D and E were more advanced then the NCC-1701 and -A ships. Although Scotty in Engineering would help the Enterprise get through it. Overall Kirk I think is a better captain. Janeway and Voyager wouldnt do good since most of the time their Phasers dont work when she gives the order to fire lol.à

If it was hand-hand combat Kirk simply would win hes a lot better fighting hand to hand then the rest of them

If you're only counting the captains on TV (not movies) I'd give it to Kirk. No one can withstand the back slam. And of all of them I think he'd be least conflicted about causing bodily harm to another person, at least until the fight is over.

Janeway has an advantage, as the others would undoubtedly feel uncomfortable hitting her, and Archer is probably the most physically fit. Though perhaps the Pine Kirk from the upcoming movie, with his youth, could win.

Jean Luc Picard

though i love jean luc picard, my gut says sisko would win in a fight between all of them, having said that i think janeway would have an advantage as none of them seem to be the kind of guys who would hit a woman

Captain Kirk- decent fist fighter- also has his special double axe handle strike

Kirk, the button from his trousers would fly off and kill picard

It would so be Kirky boy!! He looks amazing in a fight...especially when his uniform got torn!!! lol...mmmmm!!! lol!

so obvoiusly the kirk and spock combo